Skip to main content


Access and Info for Institutional Subscribers

Home
Toggle menu

  • Home
  • Editions
  • Images
    • Exhibits
    • Images
  • Teaching
    • Articles
    • Teacher Resources
  • How To
  • About COVE
    • Constitution
    • Board
    • Supporting Institutions
    • Talks / Articles
    • FAQ
    • Testimonials


Women with Mental Illness in Ruth Hall


Type: Gallery Image | Not Vetted



The same kind of internalized misogyny is evident in Fanny Fern’s Ruth Hall, most notably in the chapter in which Ruth visits the insane asylum.  The narrator seems to disapprove of the treatment of a woman who has been separated from her child and is unbalanced at least partially as a result, but we are also told that this woman is “...a sight of trouble to manage,” and liable to “spring at [children] through them bars like a panther,” (Fern 111).  And, only a few paragraphs later, the narrator says of Ruth, “Well might she shudder, as the gibbering screams of the maniacs over head echoes through the stillness of that cold, gloomy vault,” (ibid).  In other words, here, too, women with mental illness are once more portrayed as terrifying and only quasi-human, and, furthermore, it is the female matron and the presumably female narrator who do so.  This seems odd in some ways, but it is an interesting parallel with Jane Eyre.  Perhaps both texts were simply too much a product of the culture of their time to allow their female characters and narrators to care whole-heartedly about other women, especially those with mental illness.

Featured in Exhibit


Mental Health Treatment in the Victorian Era

Date


circa. 1871

Artist


James Crichton-Browne


Copyright
©

Vetted?
No
Submitted by Erin Bendy on Fri, 11/20/2020 - 11:32

Webform: Contact

About COVE

  • Constitution
  • Board
  • What's New
  • Talks / Articles
  • Testimonials

What is COVE?

COVE is Collaborative Organization for Virtual Education, a scholar-driven open-access platform that publishes both peer-reviewed material and "flipped classroom" student projects built with our online tools.

Visit our 'How To' page

sfy39587stp18